D Class self defence (in lower d block) - Denied

[Fat Payton | [GL]]

Post name: “General Suggestion - D Class self defence (in lower d block)"

What are you suggesting? - if d class are in lower and are attacked by another d class,the victim can pull out a MELEE weapon to defend themselves,but would have 3 seconds to put it away before being kos

 

However if a gun is pulled out you would still be kos,mainly to prevent players from exploiting this with guns

Also if the d class charges or trys to attack anyone else they are instantly kos

How would this change better the server? - it would help d class from being rdm'd by other d class

Are there any disadvantages of making this change to the server? If so, explain. - I dont believe so,only downsude i could see is security getting confused,thing the victim started it and killed them

Who would this change mostly benefit? - D class

Please link any workshop content, screenshots, or anything that you think may be helpful to those who view this suggestion -

Note I do think maybe d class can advert SELF DEFENCE if attacked by another d class,im not 100% sure tho,sorry if this is a bad idea,im just tired of being punched in line

[Catsro]

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

[Skela]

33 minutes ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[[GL] Mike]

34 minutes ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[Spud]

1 hour ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[OWNED]

2 hours ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

-Support

[Jack S]

2 hours ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

Catsro summed it up perfectly.

[[GL] Zeus]

-Support
I don't see a point in this rule being added tbh.

[pixalgamer99]

3 seconds isn’t even long enough too fully pull out a weapon

[Southpaw]

10 hours ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

Nothing else needs to be said here, this explains it all.

[Pills]

11 hours ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[The CI Zero]

13 hours ago, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[Squash]

-Support

Just call staff, its the most blatant types of sits and one of the easiest to handle since it shows in logs. Plus most of the time its new players who just punch you, so it does not deal a severe amount of damage, finally D Class don't have a NLR ( Except for Custom Classes ) So...

[J0LT]

HOLY SHIT +SUPPORT

i gettin mad yall killin me when im tryna protect myself

[Chief_]

-support

You realize how much this can be abused? SOmeone can get close to somebody punch a guy. The guy pulls out a weapon to "defend himself" and then attack the security.

[Mary]

On 11/30/2020 at 10:47 PM, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[Dr. Succ]

- Support

I mean c'mon, I would already be trying to kill him if he did that to me, do theirs really no point.

[Sixx]

On 11/30/2020 at 10:47 PM, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[[GL] Fizz-y Soda]

On 11/30/2020 at 9:47 PM, Catsro said:

I mean you can already defend yourself if the dclass hit you first but generally you could just call a staff sit for rdm or ardm which would easily solve this problem. Option #2 if you pull out a weapon to kill them then you are kos'd by gensec for pulling out a weapon and they are also killed lose-lose. Not sure why this would need a change cause 1 you have no nlr as dclass and 2 you could just call staff to handle the case.

 

[Nagasaki]

-support

-That would make it VERY complicated for Security  Enlisted and would cause more RDMs of Class D

-Just get a staff member for RDM

Security DHFTO 1LT Hiroshima

Edited December 14, 2020 by Nagasaki

[Mind Stone]

-Support

Staff are here for a reason. Use them.

[Phillers]

-Support, there is little to no benefit to this as you can just call staff.

[Igneous]

Denied. The SCP-RP SMT has decided against adding this suggestion for performance reasons, the benefit to the server, or another unstated reason.