Jump to content

Ireland - Staff Report- Accepted


Shin

Was this disrespectful asf?  

18 members have voted

  1. 1. Was this disrespectful asf?



Recommended Posts

Your In-game: ShinSpin

 

Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:51164718

 

The admin's name in-game: Lead Investigator Ireland

 

The admin's steam name (If you know it): STEAM_0:0:424557834

 

What did the admin do: Physgun abuse on a D-Class to gain a combat advantage.

 

Evidence of the abusive action(s) (REQUIRED):

https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/RHQEte4LhEpfV/d1337A5JYbQ4?invite=cr-MSw5UDIsMTk5MzkxNDUs

 

What do you believe should happen to the admin: Demotion to Trial Moderator 

 

Any extra information: Dawg, ain't no way he disrespect him like that.

This shit makin me cry.

david-goggins-lifting.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

+Support
Name aside of the clip using your physgun isn't allowed regardless of the situation unless the player is stuck, using your staff abilities for Rp purposes is against the rules

| EX CI General | | Ex Lead Admin | 
| The best Fruit to exist |

Link to comment
Share on other sites

51 minutes ago, GhostReaper_Eod said:

I Rp'ed Shoveing him over and he didn't so I Phis Guned him over. Also why would you Name the vid like that you trying to get yourself reported for rasicim? Also you tried to Blackmail me to let you out so you would not report me. 

why change topic.. u abusin cuh...

+support, the evidence is clear i've also banned you before when I was imperial SMT for sending a video saying pornhub kids 🤮

Edited by bop
  • Skull 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Head of Staff
12 minutes ago, bop said:

why change topic.. u abusin cuh...

+support, the evidence is clear i've also banned you before when I was imperial SMT for sending a video saying pornhub kids 🤮

Breh +support

dM43pL3.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, bop said:

why change topic.. u abusin cuh...

+support, the evidence is clear i've also banned you before when I was imperial SMT for sending a video saying pornhub kids 🤮

wtf +Support

                                                                                                                                      spacer.pngI keep a stiff upper lip and I shoot, shoot, shoot from the hip I got a stiff upper lip, come on baby.                                   

Retired Nu7 Captain/Maintenance OM

Link to comment
Share on other sites

-Support
1. It was an in-rp thing, the D class was being fed to Shinspin while he was on 682 and was shoved over the fence.

2. Mf literally put a slur in the title of the clip and broke a rule himself. Even if Ireland was in the wrong, Shinspin would be liable for breaking a rule too and the clip wouldn't be valid.

3. Tried to blackmail Ireland with the clip and tried to get blackmail him into getting him to open his CC while he was on MTF

Edited by Cintal

The Double Barrel Bandit...

Former Ranks: RRH Analyst Echo-39 - G9 Wendigo GF5 - Elite Medic - Deputy Head of Medical Research D5 2nd Lieutenant - Deputy Head Raptor Operative - GOC Private x2 - CI Sergeant - O1 Specialist x2 (first O1 enlisted) - Event Team Executive AWPD Office Manager - RAU Advanced Unit - Advanced Medic - RFA Secretary of Investigations and Counter Intelligence - RAU Sentinel Unit - D5 Sergeant Major Head of Research - CI Captain - EOI Capulet - E4 Goon

CCs owned: Class D Special Forces - Horizon Initiative Legion I II and III Horizon Initiative Apollyon Unit

Link to comment
Share on other sites

- Support

>The Evidence Contains Hate Speech/ Racial Slurs, therefore making it against Medal TV's ToS, therefore the post shouldn't be up in the first place

>As a person who served 3 years on a different server as staff, everyone makes a mistake every now and then, complete demotion down to trial mod is not just outlandish, it should be completely out of the question

>Not to mention, the point that he makes about the staff mentioned attempting to use his physgun for a combat advantage is completely irrelevant, basic training dictates that all D-Class get stripped before getting to a SCP, therefore meaning that the D class would have no chance regardless of the Physgun abuse

In Summary, while Ireland did commit Physgun abuse, the way the player reported this is entirely disrespectful to the server, the community, and Staff, Ireland via the clip, was physgunning a d-class, whom by protocol would've been stripped of all weaponry, and cuffed, therefore rendering the claim about doing this for Combat Advantage completely null.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, K I W I said:

+Support
Name aside of the clip using your physgun isn't allowed regardless of the situation unless the player is stuck, using your staff abilities for Rp purposes is against the rules

This point is kind of invalid, i've seen multiple instances of staff from Mod to senior admin to JMT use their phys gun when a player refuses to do somthing that other wise should be done [jumping over somthing when RPd to do so] The d class was not really cooperating from what i was, i'd say at the vert least an verble warning should be issued.

Former E11 Captain, D5 Sergeant, V1 [EOI], CI LT,  and Nu7 LT
Current E11 LCPL|Riot Shield Abuser|Cloak hater

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Proximo said:

This point is kind of invalid, i've seen multiple instances of staff from Mod to senior admin to JMT use their phys gun when a player refuses to do somthing that other wise should be done [jumping over somthing when RPd to do so] The d class was not really cooperating from what i was, i'd say at the vert least an verble warning should be issued.

Anecdotal, this clip is clear that he did it, just cause you've seen others do it doesn't mean it's right. And Senior admin and JMT can use their powers off duty so that's invalid anyways.

Edited by K I W I

| EX CI General | | Ex Lead Admin | 
| The best Fruit to exist |

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, K I W I said:

Anecdotal as fuck, this clip is clear that he did it, just cause you've seen others do it doesn't mean it's right. And Senior admin and JMT can use their powers off duty so that's invalid anyways.

If its counted as abuse than why would it be acceptable on any class, also why would it be a 2 rank demotion and not a strike or 1 rank demotion, doesn't make too much sense. [ill move away from the admin topic]

Former E11 Captain, D5 Sergeant, V1 [EOI], CI LT,  and Nu7 LT
Current E11 LCPL|Riot Shield Abuser|Cloak hater

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Agent Green said:

- Support

>The Evidence Contains Hate Speech/ Racial Slurs, therefore making it against Medal TV's ToS, therefore the post shouldn't be up in the first place

>As a person who served 3 years on a different server as staff, everyone makes a mistake every now and then, complete demotion down to trial mod is not just outlandish, it should be completely out of the question

>Not to mention, the point that he makes about the staff mentioned attempting to use his physgun for a combat advantage is completely irrelevant, basic training dictates that all D-Class get stripped before getting to a SCP, therefore meaning that the D class would have no chance regardless of the Physgun abuse

In Summary, while Ireland did commit Physgun abuse, the way the player reported this is entirely disrespectful to the server, the community, and Staff, Ireland via the clip, was physgunning a d-class, whom by protocol would've been stripped of all weaponry, and cuffed, therefore rendering the claim about doing this for Combat Advantage completely null.

 

25 minutes ago, Cintal said:

-Support
1. It was an in-rp thing, the D class was being fed to Shinspin while he was on 682 and was shoved over the fence.

2. Mf literally put a slur in the title of the clip and broke a rule himself. Even if Ireland was in the wrong, Shinspin would be liable for breaking a rule too and the clip wouldn't be valid.

3. Tried to blackmail Ireland with the clip and tried to get blackmail him into getting him to open his CC while he was on MTF

Uh so I was actually the person Ireland physgunned into 682 (I believe you can see my name in the clip when shinspin uses his mic, check top left corner and when I type) and I want to clarify some things.

There was no RP pushing me into the 682 CC, as you can see quite clearly in the clip I was not cuffed and had not been priorly stripped so I am not sure why you got this impression. 


I was not being fed to 682, I was actually very close to breaching 682 before Ireland came in and shot me in the back earlier before this clip, I was once again trying to breach 682 but found out Ireland was still in the CC and decided to just wait outside the door before the D5 2LT found me, I told him I wanted to breach 682 but Ireland was in there so he brought me inside, we spoke for like 10-15 seconds before Ireland used his physgun to drop me into the CC, again there was no RP pushes into the CC from either MTF members. 

As for the title of the clip I completely agree that it was a racial slur and don't understand why he titled it that. 


Also I DO NOT BELIEVE this physgun abuse is gaining a combat advantage and certainly should not result in a demotion, perhaps a reprimanding but even that I dont think is necessary.

Loves Corners, Corner. Corner. 

Former Imperial Commandos VCMDR Fixer 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...