staffreport Watermelon - Trial Moderator Report- Denied

[Eris-Proxis-Silver]

Questions

1. Your In-game: Silver 

2. Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:195485792 

3. The admin's name in-game: Watermelon

 

4. The admin's steam name (If you know it): [GL] Crazyboyri | STEAM_0:0:145670367

 

5. What did the admin do: Prop Abuse - For a while now (2 weeks or so) Watermelon ( Hereby referred to as The Defendant) has been on and off of the staff job abusing the props by blocking vital areas of the map, such as bridge brig EC and ER. The Defendant has been spoken to by rangiatea to not abuse props be we wish to take it further. The Defendant was claiming to have permission from Morningstar (A.K.A Luci/Lucifer) for several months now and this is clearly false. I have spoken to luci and he has said that he has not asked for permission 

 

6. Evidence of the abusive action(s) (REQUIRED): https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1NE42XHi-npJ2WIzY79koBGY2AR_1zlU1?ths=true

 

7. What do you believe should happen to the admin: Staff Restriction and a Removal

 

8. Any extra information: The Defendant is not even a Gamemaster he’s just a TMOD who thinks he is still a SMOD and even admitted that he was removed

 

I Have tagged people on the forums in this post as they said they would be an accountable witness and to vouch for me that this was as serious as we are making it out to be

Tags: @Tealfaded @Isaac. @Dontchooseit67 @Rangiatea

Edited December 29, 2020 by SilversVids
Edit Reason: Punishment Length Change

[Some Weeb]

That punishment is super exaggerated a restriction and a 2 month ban??? 

Also witnesses are not really credible 

-support for the punishment listed above 

If anything +support on a removal and restriction 

@Crazyboyri your side?

[Frosty_]

+Support

- Though I believe the punishment is way to high I do believe he should be punished

 

[mikey!]

9 minutes ago, Blizzard said:

+Support

- Though I believe the punishment is way to high I do believe he should be punished

 

 

[Axle]

38 minutes ago, Blizzard said:

+Support

- Though I believe the punishment is way to high I do believe he should be punished

 

+ Support as well, I provided some photo evidence for this report as well as witnessed it myself on multiple occasions, and I believe that this kind of thing should not be acceptable as it is directly interfering with the RP experience of the players. I do agree that the ban may be a bit much, But I believe a staff restriction is necessary as this has been a serious and repetitive problem.

+ Have witnessed these issues myself

+ photo evidence included 

+ The staff in question lied about having permission from Head Admin Luci to do this

+ Punishment no longer includes the ban, I believe now that this form should be accepted in it’s entirety.

Edited December 29, 2020 by Tealfaded
The punishment attached to this report was changed, and therefor my opinion on it has changed as well.

[TAlila | Tay Keith!]

-/+ Support
-I believe the punishment is high, Especially for someone who is brand new to the staff team and is encouraged to learn from their superiors. 
-He put props down with the intent of keeping the server safer, Although he should've handled the situation completely differently
-Allegedly Lied about getting SMT's Permission

In the end it's up to SMT  Although I feel like he had good intentions, Just executed poorly

Edited December 29, 2020 by TAlila | Tay Keith!

[Crazyboyri]

I put it there to keep the server safe, I had to many minge and troop going into brig with out authorization and letting people out. I have done this in past and Luci ok this while back to keep the server under control. I have never had an issue in pass and I kept the server safe as well. Putting me as removel and staff restricted is high punishment. I wanted to keep the server safe from people breaking the rule and people minge at 12AM thru 6AM everyday and I did my best to do what right. There weren't any staff on at the times, there were so much problem to deal with so I block Brig area for bit to keep everything under control.

[Axle]

5 hours ago, Crazyboyri said:

I put it there to keep the server safe, I had to many minge and troop going into brig with out authorization and letting people out. I have done this in past and Luci ok this while back to keep the server under control. I have never had an issue in pass and I kept the server safe as well. Putting me as removel and staff restricted is high punishment. I wanted to keep the server safe from people breaking the rule and people minge at 12AM thru 6AM everyday and I did my best to do what right. There weren't any staff on at the times, there were so much problem to deal with so I block Brig area for bit to keep everything under control.

The part about there being no staff on simply isn’t true. Both myself and @Isaac. were on and we both asked you to remove the prop however you refused. Things were not out of control either, their were plenty of people guarding Brig, and the people who were escaping were exploiting the map to do so, not being released by others. Even so what you did directly interfered with the role play, and prevented access to a vital area of the ship on more occasions than just this one. This also prevents anyone who was falsely arrested from being unarrested without the help of an Admin, and you went AFK shortly after the prop was placed, when it should have at the very least been your responsibility to deal with things in brig, as you were the one who placed the prop.

[Crazyboyri]

They can guard brig but there wont be anyone to guard BCP. I put a wall there to get the situation under control because I keep hearing that people were getting out of jail by other people for opening the cell door without authorization. I needed to block it off for a bit to get everything under control. I just don't understand why you guy have to make a big deal out of it because all you guy were being rude to me when you're suppose to help me keep the server safe. I've been taking sit and people were turning power off or opening brig cell door to let people out and etc and I was only one on at the times so I block it off.

[Alexxxx]

17 minutes ago, Dragin said:

I would also like to add we had several issues with watermelon on shock e.x allowing sts to walk around with improper names 

That has nothing to do with this current Situation

[Crazyboyri]

That is not part of this current situation and I wasn't on my shock jobs

[TAlila | Tay Keith!]

Hey guys, I wouldn't advise arguing as this will get locked by a Forums Diplomat. Both parties has left their responses, and it's up to SMT to decide whether the report is valid or not

[Stone Man]

22 hours ago, TAlila | Tay Keith! said:

-/+ Support
-I believe the punishment is high, Especially for someone who is brand new to the staff team and is encouraged to learn from their superiors. 
-He put props down with the intent of keeping the server safer, Although he should've handled the situation completely differently
-Allegedly Lied about getting SMT's Permission

In the end it's up to SMT  Although I feel like he had good intentions, Just executed poorly

I believe a strike and or a staff retraining would be a more appropriate punishment given the circumstances. Either way -Support for the punishments suggested. 

[[GL] Lucifer]

DENIED

With already speaking with @Crazyboyri about the situation it wasn't considerably terrible due to him having a miscommunication issue with SMT's previous orders, as idea shows he has good intent, though @Crazyboyri speak to me whenever you're available.